Business disputes arise every day. For example, a supplier violates a provision of an exclusivity contract ... a publisher infringes on a writer's copyright ... or a competitor steals a trade secret. These wrongdoings typically result in one party losing money. It's up to the legal system to restore order -- and award economic damages.
Here we discuss some approaches to quantifying economic damages, as well as potential pitfalls and contentious issues that may arise.
A damages calculation starts with a theory that links the actions of the defendant to a loss incurred by the plaintiff. For example, "But for Mr. X's copyright infringement, ABC Company would have earned $x more in pretax profits from 2011 through 2014."
Courts award damages to make the plaintiff "whole" again. Generally, damages are calculated on a pre-tax basis, because plaintiffs typically owe taxes on compensatory damages awards.
Defendants aren't responsible for losses caused by external factors. For example, damages calculations should exclude losses caused by increased competition in the marketplace or by an economic downturn. In today's uncertain economy, it can be tricky to separate losses caused by a defendant's alleged wrongdoing from losses caused by external events.
When persuading the courts to accept a damages calculation, a valuator typically uses one (or more) of several generally accepted methods, such as the:
There's no universally accepted method for quantifying economic damages. Appraisers customize their approach on a case-by-case basis -- and often they use more than one method to support their opinions.
Damages calculations are a matter of professional opinion. Two competent appraisers employing sound methodology are unlikely to arrive at exactly the same conclusion. Subjective assumptions include:
Courts may not embrace damages calculations that fail to establish causation or to mitigate damages. After a defendant's wrongdoing is revealed, the plaintiff has an obligation to mitigate damages, if possible.
Estimating lost profits is a natural extension of a valuator's skill set. Damages calculations require an understanding of accounting, financial analysis and forecasting, industry and economic trends, and the time value of money. Qualified appraisers also know about relevant legal precedent and how to effectively testify in court.
Get in touch today and find out how we can help you meet your objectives.