If you own shares in a closely held corporation and are considering converting some or all of the ownership into cash, a corporate stock redemption can be an effective strategy especially under today’s relatively favorable individual federal income tax rates. However, the tax consequences depend heavily on structure, stock-basis, and applicable rules. This guide walks you through the key considerations, tax treatment, and planning strategies for stock redemptions in 2025.
A stock redemption occurs when your company buys back and redeems some or all of your shares in exchange for cash. For private businesses, this can offer liquidity, a path to partial or complete exit, or a way to rebalance ownership.
Stock redemption can be appealing now because individual tax rates including those on capital gains and qualified dividends remain at historically favorable levels.
How a redemption is taxed depends on whether the transaction qualifies as a sales exchange or is treated as a corporate distribution under IRS rules.
Under certain conditions, a redemption can be treated as a sale or exchange of stock which usually yields capital gains tax treatment instead of dividend treatment.
To qualify for sale/exchange treatment, the redemption must meet one of several exceptions, such as:
Sales exchange treatment often means only the amount you receive above your basis gets taxed typically at capital gains rates which can be considerably more favorable than ordinary dividend income.
If your business is an S-corporation, redemption rules differ, but similar principles apply. Under many circumstances, redemptions may qualify for sales exchange treatment; but if certain corporate attributes (e.g., accumulated E&P from a prior C-Corp status) exist, the redemption may trigger distribution-style taxation.
Because of these nuances, especially family-owned or closely held S-corps, careful planning and documentation are critical if you aim for favorable tax treatment.
Favorable tax rates: With capital gains and qualified dividend rates near historical lows, both distribution and sales exchange outcomes are relatively attractive depending on your basis and corporate earnings. Liquidity need or succession planning: Redemption can provide cash for retirement, estate planning, or transfer ownership especially in family corporations or when preparing for generational transitions.
Flexibility for shareholders: By redeeming shares, you may reduce personal exposure, simplify ownership structure, or diversify personal holdings, converting embedded equity into usable cash. That said because future tax law changes remain uncertain, taking advantage of current favorable rates while they last is often advised for those considering redemption.
Suppose you don't have a significant tax basis in the redeemed shares or any significant capital losses. In that case, there's usually only a minor distinction between dividend treatment and stock sale treatment under today's individual federal income tax rate structure. Under current tax law, both dividends and long-term capital gains (LTCGs) are taxed at the same maximum federal rate of 23.8%. This includes the 20% maximum rate for LTCGs and qualified dividends, plus another 3.8% for the net investment income tax (NIIT). This maximum rate applies only to high-income taxpayers. Here are the thresholds for the maximum rate for 2025:
Most people are subject to a 15% LTCG and qualified dividend tax rate, plus 3.8% for the NIIT if applicable. Taxpayers with modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) over $200,000 per year ($250,000 for married filing jointly and $125,000 for married filing separately) are subject to the extra 3.8% NIIT on the lesser of their net investment income or the amount by which their MAGI exceeds the applicable threshold. Net investment income can include capital gains, dividends, interest and other investment-related income (but not self-rental income from an active trade or business).
A corporate stock redemption can be an excellent way for business owners to access built-up equity, prepare for retirement or succession, or reposition holdings. But the tax outcome hinges on how the redemption is structured and whether the transaction qualifies as a sale/exchange rather than a dividend.
Before moving ahead, it’s wise to:
When done correctly with effective planning and documentation, stock redemption remains a powerful tool for business-owner liquidity, succession, and tax strategy.
Stock redemptions take time to implement properly. If you're interested in taking advantage of this strategy, contact your Porte Brown tax advisor to understand the tax implications fully and get the ball rolling.
Stock sale treatment will always apply to an S corporation stock redemption unless the company has earnings and profits (E&P) from an earlier period as a C corporation. Corporate distribution treatment applies if the S corporation has E&P, and those rules get tricky. When corporate distribution treatment applies, stock redemption payments received by shareholders are treated as taxable dividends to the extent of the corporation's E&P. However, stock sale treatment will apply even if the S corporation has E&P if an exception is available (see main article).
Get in touch today and find out how we can help you meet your objectives.
