Commissions can motivate your organization's sales staff, but poorly designed or loosely monitored incentive programs may also encourage manipulation. A salesperson who falsifies a transaction, inflates revenue or claims credit for another employee's work could potentially receive unearned compensation.
The damage may extend beyond improper payments. Fraudulent sales can distort financial reports, forecasts, inventory decisions and tax filings — possibly leading to costly consequences. To prevent such results, your business needs clear commission rules and controls that verify sales before any money changes hands.
Commission fraud can take several forms. A retail employee might enter a nonexistent transaction into a point-of-sale system or create a fictitious customer, contract or invoice. Or an employee might inflate a legitimate order, record a sale twice or change a transaction date to meet a monthly or quarterly target.
Other schemes are less obvious. A salesperson could claim credit for a colleague's sale, manipulate split commissions or arrange for a customer to place an order that will be canceled after the commission is paid. Returns, rebates and credit memos may be concealed or delayed. Dishonest employees might also apply unauthorized discounts or favorable contract terms to boost volume.
Also watch the activities of sales managers with access to commission settings. They could raise a pay rate or change a territory assignment. Those without access might collude with an accounting, payroll or information technology worker who does.
In general, fraud risk rises when commission plans are overly complex or sales targets are unrealistic and impossible to achieve. If your employees don't understand how compensation is calculated, or believe they must meet aggressive quotas at any cost, misconduct may be easier for wrongdoers to rationalize.
Commission fraud often leaves patterns in sales, payroll and customer data. Look for these potential red flags:
No single indicator proves fraud. A skilled salesperson may have a legitimate explanation for unusual results. However, you should document and investigate any exceptions. Be sure to compare total commission expense with sales revenue, gross profit and cash collections.
In addition, randomly sample transactions that have generated commissions and trace them from the original customer order through approval, shipment, invoicing, payment and commission calculation. When appropriate, verify selected transactions with customers as part of routine satisfaction or quality-control calls.
Automated data analysis can make reviews even more efficient. Your accounting or commission-management system may be able to flag duplicate invoices, manual overrides, sales to newly created customers, unusual round-dollar transactions and commissions connected to later refunds. Be sure to preserve system audit trails so reviewers can determine who created or changed a record and when. Monitoring employee email, texts or phone calls may uncover evidence of collusion, but it can also raise privacy issues. So consult legal counsel before establishing a monitoring program.
Effective controls stop improper commissions before payment. For example, when possible, assign different employees to record sales, approve adjustments, calculate commissions and release payroll. Supervisors should independently approve new customers, unusual discounts, manual commission changes and transactions above established thresholds.
Consider paying commissions only after a sale has met clearly defined requirements, such as delivery, expiration of the cancellation period or customer payment. Written plans should explain how returns, bad debts, partial payments, canceled contracts, split sales and disputed accounts affect compensation. Where permitted by law, include provisions that allow your business to recover overpayments resulting from errors or misconduct. Managers should review exception reports and reconcile commission calculations to approved source data before processing payroll.
Finally, maintain a confidential reporting channel that employees, customers and vendors can access by web, email or phone. This remains important because tips beat other methods of detecting occupational fraud (43% of cases, according to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners).
A strong commission program encourages profitable sales without creating opportunities to alter results. Clear compensation terms, realistic goals, restricted system access and regular transaction reviews can protect your business while helping to ensure employees are paid accurately. Contact your financial advisor for help analyzing commission data and the controls surrounding your sales and payroll processes.
Get in touch today and find out how we can help you meet your objectives.
